Wednesday, June 01
This one sentence from that Newsweek article, out of all the nonsense and blather, has been niggling at me:
World War II was fought not just to defeat the Axis powers, but to make the world safe for the United Nations, the precursor to the World Trade Organization, the European Union and other international institutions that would strengthen weaker countries.It's just so wrong, so irredeemably and inexcusably wrong.
Who were the Axis powers? Primarily, Germany, Italy and Japan. Spain was aligned with them; Hitler and Mussolini lent support to Franco in the Spanish Civil War. There were a number of other minor partners; Finland, for example, aligned itself with Germany because it saw Russia as a graver threat.
What was the war about? Germany, Italy and Japan wanted to secure more land and resources. Germany in Europe; Italy (as a lesser partner) would take the uninteresting bits of Europe (like Albania) and Africa; Japan would take eastern Asia and the Pacific. Look at this handy little map to see what they were up to.
Who opposed them? Well, Austria, Czechoslovakia and Poland, early targets during the war in Europe, simply didn't have the military strength to stop the Axis. Japan had already invaded Manchuria in 1931* and was expanding its presence there. There were three powers in the world that posed a significant threat: Britain, particularly the Royal Navy; Russia; and the United States.
The Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact (a non-aggression pact between Russia and Germany) dealt with Russia. Russia was ill-prepared for war at the time, having systematically destroyed the effectiveness of its own army through purges. Britain was more of a problem; the hope there was that it could be isolated until Germany and Italy had consolidated their position in Europe.
As for the United States, the chief plan was not to get them involved in the war. That may sound like a dreadful miscalculation, but in 1935 Congress had passed the Neutrality Act, which prohibited American support for any nation at war. The Act was renewed as late as 1939. American isolationism was in full flower in the 1930's, and the Axis powers were banking on it.
Then, of course, they screwed everything up. With a characteristic combination of paranoia and overconfidence, in 1941 Germany declared war on Russia and Japan declared war on the United States. The two sleeping giants were called into play in the war against the Axis, and after four more years of terrible bloodshed, the Axis was finally crushed.
World War II was entirely about the ambitions of the Axis powers. America wanted only to keep to itself; Britain had its Commonwealth; Russia was in no shape to do anything. Germany, Italy and Japan decided to take over the world. It sounds crazy. It was crazy. Something like 50 million people died for their ambitions.†
I wonder why Newsweek wants us to believe otherwise.
* The League of Nations, the UN of the day, did nothing.
† Estimates vary significantly in many cases.
Footnote: Britannica Online has this appalling bit of doublethink:
Axis PowersCoalition headed by Germany, Italy, and Japan that opposed the Allied Powers in World War II.
Posted by: Pixy Misa at
08:40 PM
| Comments (7)
| Add Comment
| Trackbacks (Suck)
Post contains 534 words, total size 4 kb.
I completely agree, but I like the way Wolfgang Pauli put it - "This paper is so bad it is not even wrong."
Posted by: allagash at Thursday, June 02 2005 10:01 AM (M5ajh)
Posted by: Susie at Friday, June 03 2005 05:07 PM (V1YvO)
Posted by: A Finn at Monday, June 06 2005 07:40 AM (lGolT)
Posted by: A Finn at Monday, June 06 2005 07:54 AM (lGolT)
Posted by: Pixy Misa at Monday, June 06 2005 07:59 AM (+S1Ft)
Posted by: Pixy Misa at Monday, June 06 2005 08:18 AM (+S1Ft)
Posted by: A Finn at Thursday, June 16 2005 05:44 PM (lGolT)
56 queries taking 0.1533 seconds, 353 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.