Thursday, August 31

Geek

Daily News Stuff 31 August 2023

Undeducted Edition 

Top Story

  • OpenAI has disputed the claims in a class action suit brought by various authors such as Richard Kadrey, and "authors" such as Sarah Silverman, responding with your momma is a derivative work.  (Ars Technica)
    Authors claim generative AI is just a "grift" that repackages original works.
    The first half of this is self-evident.

    The second half is like saying steak is just repackaged carbon dioxide.  Yes.  Grass absorbs carbon dioxide from the atmosphere to grow.  Cows eat grass.  People eat cows.

    But the carbon dioxide is free, so it's irrelevant.

    In just the same way, authors - and "authors" - repackage the work of previous authors.  We accept this if they're sufficiently subtle about it, and the flavour comes out different, just like cows and grass.

    We don't expect grass to pay for the right to absorb carbon dioxide from the air, nor do we require authors to pay commercial licenses for the books they read as they learn to write.

    But if we are served a plate of alleged steak, and it is green and leafy, we tend to riot and burn the restaurant down.  Metaphorically.

    Much as I loathe OpenAI as a bunch of useless grifters, what they are doing is clearly fair use under US law.  Which doesn't mean they will win in court, and certainly doesn't mean that that the law won't end up changing.

    It just means that they are right.


Tech News


Disclaimer: Kemal Ataturk owned an entire menagerie of animals all named Abdul.

Posted by: Pixy Misa at 05:43 PM | Comments (1) | Add Comment | Trackbacks (Suck)
Post contains 610 words, total size 5 kb.

1 "Apparently a factor in this decision was the argument that such legislation would unfairly burden the LGBTQ+ community."
Does being 2SLGBTQIA++= make it hard to find the local DMV or something?

Posted by: Rick C at Thursday, August 31 2023 11:48 PM (BMUHC)

Hide Comments | Add Comment




Apple pies are delicious. But never mind apple pies. What colour is a green orange?




52kb generated in CPU 0.0194, elapsed 0.7064 seconds.
58 queries taking 0.6957 seconds, 338 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.