Friday, July 12

Geek

Daily News Stuff 12 July 2024

Dead Intranet Theory Edition

Top Story

  • Could AIs become conscious? Right now, we have no way to tell.  (Ars Technica)

    Because we haven't properly defined the terms.

    What kind of AI?  SHRDLU from 1968 (yes, I keep mentioning that) displayed more evidence of consciousness than ChatGPT, and examining its abilities we see clear indications of a primitive level of conscious.

    There's a term in AI, sphexishness, referring to the golden digger wasp, Sphex ichneumoneus.  Like many wasps, the sphex wasp will paralyse its prey to serve as food for its larvae.  In this case it will paralyse an insect, drag it back to its burrow (it's a digger wasp), check that the burrow is safe, and then put the prey in the burrow to serve as a larder for the baby sphexes.

    The thing is, if you move the paralysed insect while the sphex is checking the burrow, it will move it back next to the burrow, inspect the burrow again, and then drag it into the burrow.

    And if you move the insect again while the sphex is re-checking the burrow, the cycle will repeat.  No matter how many times you do this, the sphex will not change its behaviour.

    SHRDLU was able to explain why it did what it did, step by step.  It didn't get angry at being given repeated nonsensical orders, but it could account for every action that it took.

    Anyway, can computers become conscious?  Well, they are already more conscious than insects, and have been for decades.

    Can computers become conscious with all the complexity as human consciousness?  Certainly not currently; they are not remotely powerful enough.

    Can LLMs become conscious?  A single LLM, no.  LLMs are designed specifically to avoid that.

    A pair of LLMs in a feedback loop?  Maybe, yes.  But likely also psychotic.


Tech News


Disclaimer: Node.js is the prostate cancer of Computer Science.

Posted by: Pixy Misa at 06:35 PM | Comments (3) | Add Comment | Trackbacks (Suck)
Post contains 564 words, total size 5 kb.

1 Leet me just say, Pixy, you managed to extract an actual laugh on nearly every bullet point to-day.  Thank you, you awesome person!  The world  is going to shit, and the people who are supposedly reporting on it are shit, but we still have snarky commentary on the shit.

Posted by: normal at Friday, July 12 2024 07:06 PM (bg2DR)

2 Sumerian Game isn't quite as lost to time as that article suggests; a company named HareSoft (or Hare Soft?) has rebuilt it, and it's evidently coming to Steam soon(ish).

Posted by: CanajunXYZ at Saturday, July 13 2024 02:57 AM (4MQvG)

3 I saw Sumerian Game open for Enkidu at Ye Olde Tavern.

Posted by: Rick C at Saturday, July 13 2024 01:00 PM (gFAd+)

Hide Comments | Add Comment




Apple pies are delicious. But never mind apple pies. What colour is a green orange?




53kb generated in CPU 0.0123, elapsed 0.0972 seconds.
58 queries taking 0.0902 seconds, 347 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.